Gifts for the Kid Who Has Everything

Stumped by the kid whose toy bin is already full? These are the unexpected picks from real Wish Well wishlists — novelty, charm, and things they definitely don’t already own.

Every gift in this guide was added to a real child's wishlist by a real family on Wish Well.

Blinger Diamond Starter Kit

$35.00

The gem stamper — bedazzle hair, jackets, and inevitably the dog. A pure novelty hit.

View on Amazon

ZURU 5 Surprise Mini Brands Capsule

$19.99

A five-layer surprise capsule — the unboxing format kids are obsessed with, in miniature.

View on Amazon

Fancy Dress Bath Time Stickers

$29.99

Dress-up stickers for the bathtub — turns bath night into costume night.

View on Amazon

Maileg Matchbox Mice

$31.00

Danish matchbox mice with tiny beds and tinier pajamas. Heirloom-cute.

View on Mailegusa

Jellycat Amuseables Sun

$35.00

Jellycat’s smiling sun — for the kid who already owns every plush animal.

View on Jellycat

Marvel Spidey Tonie

$19.99

Drop it on the Toniebox and it tells stories. Collectible and actually useful.

View on Tonies

Puffy Charms Kit

$29.99

Squishy charm jewelry they make themselves — craft and accessory in one.

View on Lakeshore Learning

Crystal Gem Dragon Figurine

$25.00

A hand-finished crystal dragon from an Etsy maker. Shelf-worthy for years.

View on Etsy

Doctor Squish Squishy Maker Station

$29.99

For the squishy collector who has them all: the machine to make their own.

View on Amazon